Debt capitalisation is a practical solution that companies may use both for growth and for financial stabilisation. In essence, it means that a creditor converts its claim against a company into a contribution to the company’s share capital, thereby becoming a shareholder.
Legal Framework
A claim against a company may become a contribution to its share capital through an increase of the share capital, with the creditor becoming a shareholder of the company. The company’s share capital is increased and its financial indicators improve, while the obligation itself is extinguished by merger. Under the Civil Law, the creditor and the debtor become one and the same person (in this case, the company). The result is a conversion of debt into equity, i.e. debt capitalisation.
This is possible because, under the Commercial Law, share capital may be paid up in money or by a contribution in kind. A contribution in kind may consist of both corporeal and incorporeal things that can be valued in monetary terms, except for things against which recovery cannot be enforced under the law. Pursuant to the Civil Law, incorporeal things include various personal, property and obligation rights, insofar as they form part of a person’s property.
The Commercial Law requires a contribution in kind to be valued by a qualified appraiser who issues an opinion, except in the following cases:
1. the founders themselves may carry out the valuation if, upon the establishment of a limited liability company (SIA), the total value of contributions in kind does not exceed EUR 25,000 and the contributions in kind together amount to less than half of the share capital;
2. the opinion may be provided by the company’s management board if, upon an increase of the share capital, the contribution in kind does not exceed EUR 50,000;
3. the management board also prepares the valuation where, upon the establishment of a company or an increase of its share capital, this is done by capitalising a loan disbursed by non-cash payment.
This gives shareholders greater flexibility in deciding on smaller contributions in kind and confers additional powers and responsibilities on management boards. This option is particularly relevant, for example, in the development of start-ups when capitalising investors’ claims, as well as for reducing the costs of raising capital and the administrative burden.
What Does This Mean in Practice?
In practice, a contribution in kind may consist of corporeal things, such as a vehicle, as well as incorporeal things, which include obligation rights, for example, a claim arising from a loan agreement concluded with an SIA and intended for its development, such as the acquisition of real estate or other needs.
A common example is where the owner of a company has invested their private funds in its business. Converting the debt owed to the owner into share capital improves the company’s balance sheet and creditworthiness. It is also an effective solution in crisis situations, where the creditor is willing to accept shareholder status in the company in place of debt recovery.
It is important to bear in mind that the fair value of a debt is determined in light of the company’s ability to repay it. Where the reason for capitalisation is the company’s inability to meet its obligations, the valuation carried out by a qualified appraiser will usually be lower than the nominal value of the debt. The debt is valued on the basis of the reasons for and circumstances of the capitalisation.
For example, where an SIA has negative equity and wishes to improve its financial indicators by capitalising creditors’ claims, it must be taken into account that the appraiser will consider the fact that the SIA does not in fact have sufficient funds to repay the debt to the creditor. (As mentioned above, there are cases where a valuation is not required.) Consequently, a contribution in kind of EUR 100,000 may in fact be valued at only EUR 70,000, and the creditor will lose the remaining portion upon the merger of the obligation and the extinguishment of the claim.
It should be noted, however, that the extent of the extinguished obligation must correspond to the amount of the contributed claim rather than its actual value. Therefore, although the Civil Law provides that, where a right and an obligation coincide only in part, the claim itself is extinguished only in the corresponding proportion, this does not apply to cases where the value of the contribution has been assessed below the nominal value of the claim. For example, a loan agreement was concluded for EUR 500,000, but the real estate acquired by the SIA with this amount is worth only EUR 450,000.
This article does not constitute legal advice for any specific situation. Appropriate legal solutions may vary depending on the particular facts and circumstances of each case.
Article written by: Elīna Vītola

